| Diamond Crossing School | 4.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 30 | 30.0 | Amish |
| Cranberry Marsh School | 5.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 20 | 20.0 | Amish |
| Peachtown Elementary School | 8.5 |
Regular elementary or secondary | Pre-KG-7 | 30 | 6.2 | Nonsectarian |
| West Wood Mennonite School | 8.7 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 28 | 14.0 | Mennonite |
| Chubb Hollow Mennonite School | 9.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 28 | 14.0 | Mennonite |
| Townline School | 9.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 28 | 14.0 | Mennonite |
| Kashong School | 9.5 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 33 | 16.5 | Mennonite |
| Spring Hill Mennonite School | 9.6 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 30 | 15.0 | Mennonite |
| Fayette Mennonite School | 9.8 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 37 | 12.3 | Mennonite |
| Walnut View Mennonite School | 10.9 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 31 | 15.5 | Nonsectarian |
| St Michaels Elementary School | 11.0 |
Regular elementary or secondary | Pre-KG-5 | 68 | 10.3 | Roman Catholic |
| Meadow Lane School | 11.3 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 20 | 12.5 | Mennonite |
| Wood Corner Mennonite School | 11.4 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 21 | 10.5 | Mennonite |
| Benton Mennonite School | 12.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 32 | 16.0 | Mennonite |
| Sunny Haven Mennonite School | 12.2 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-7 | 14 | 14.0 | Mennonite |
| Sunny View Mennonite School | 12.4 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 20 | 10.0 | Mennonite |
| New Conquest Mennonite School | 12.7 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 27 | 13.5 | Mennonite |
| Pine Grove Mennonite School | 13.9 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 15 | 15.0 | Mennonite |
| Frontenac Sda Elementary School | 14.4 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 2-8 | 11 | 10.0 | Seventh-Day Adventist |
| Scenic Valley Mennonite School | 14.6 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 18 | 18.0 | Mennonite |
| Valley View School | 14.7 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 21 | 11.1 | Mennonite |
| St Francis De Sales-st Stephen | 14.9 |
Regular elementary or secondary | Pre-KG-8 | 158 | 13.6 | Roman Catholic |
| Children's Hours School | 15.0 |
Alternative/other | Pre-KG-1 | 7 | 2.1 | Nonsectarian |
| Pine Glen Mennonite School | 17.0 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 25 | 12.5 | Mennonite |
| Gravel Run Mennonite School | 17.8 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 20 | 20.0 | Mennonite |
| Hickory Knoll School | 18.9 |
Alternative/other | 1-8 | 24 | 12.0 | Mennonite |
| Montessori School Of The Finger Lakes | 21.9 |
Montessori | Pre-KG-5 | 18 | 2.5 | Christian (no specific denomination) |
| Summerhill Parochial School | 22.2 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 16 | 16.0 | Amish |
| Ss Peter & Paul Ukrainian Catholic School | 22.4 |
Regular elementary or secondary | KG-8 | 102 | 10.4 | Roman Catholic |
| Ithaca Montessori School | 22.4 |
Montessori | Pre-KG-KG | 6 | 1.4 | Nonsectarian |
| St Joseph School | 22.8 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 163 | 11.8 | Roman Catholic |
| Immaculate Conception School | 24.0 |
Regular elementary or secondary | Pre-KG-8 | 99 | 9.0 | Roman Catholic |
| Clyde Mennonite Parochial School | 24.2 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-8 | 36 | 12.4 | Mennonite |
