| Hickory Hollow Amish School | 0.0 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 22 | 22.0 | Amish |
| Oak Grove Parochial School | 3.6 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 28 | 28.0 | Amish |
| Sunny Spot School | 5.4 |
Special education | Ungraded-Ungraded | 5 | 2.4 | Amish |
| Lone Maple Amish School | 10.2 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 26 | 16.2 | Amish |
| Indiana Wesleyan School | 13.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | KG-12 | 31 | 6.2 | Methodist |
| New Bethlehem Wesleyan Methodist School | 14.7 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 2-9 | 5 | 5.0 | Methodist |
| Punxsutawney Christian School | 15.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | Pre-KG-12 | 144 | 9.9 | Christian (no specific denomination) |
| Calvary Baptist Academy | 15.3 |
Regular elementary or secondary | Pre-KG-12 | 73 | 7.8 | Baptist |
| Highland Park | 15.5 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 16 | 16.0 | Amish |
| Faith Christian Academy | 16.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-12 | 12 | 12.0 | Christian (no specific denomination) |
| Aultman Baptist Church Academy | 18.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 2-12 | 6 | 1.7 | Baptist |
| Aultman Baptist Church Academy | 18.1 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 2-12 | 6 | 2.3 | Baptist |
| New Bethlehem Mennonite | 18.5 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 26 | 8.7 | Mennonite |
| Christ's Dominion Academy | 20.0 |
Alternative/other | KG-10 | 14 | 2.8 | Christian (no specific denomination) |
| Valley View School | 20.4 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 29 | 29.0 | Amish |
| Maple Grove Amish School | 20.5 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-9 | 24 | 21.8 | Amish |
| Worthington Baptist Christian Academy | 22.0 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 6-10 | 8 | 7.3 | Baptist |
| Orchard Hills Christian Academy | 23.6 |
Regular elementary or secondary | KG-11 | 33 | 4.7 | Christian (no specific denomination) |
| Otterbein Christian Academy | 24.5 |
Regular elementary or secondary | 1-11 | 21 | 9.1 | Christian (no specific denomination) |
